Skip to main content

deFacto Global Inc.

Optimization in a planning system is the cheapest solver engine that returns a feasible answer within the decision window, and then a scenario finance can run as a plan.

Optimization

For FP&A teams, that means Goal Seek and Excel Solver for standard what-if and a ladder of more powerful solvers (from open-source to top commercial partnerships) for larger, constrained, or complex problems. The result writes back into the plan as a named scenario. deFacto overall satisfaction: 4.93 vs. industry average 4.40 (BPM Partners 2025 Vendor Landscape Matrix, July 2025).

How to evaluate optimization in a planning platform

The first question is, what problem class does your team actually need to solve? Standard FP&A what-if: “What revenue target requires what cost reduction?” is a Goal Seek problem. Constrained product-mix: “given labor limits and margin objectives, what is the optimal product mix?” is a small linear programming problem. Network supply chain optimization: “what is the optimal multi-echelon inventory and distribution plan?” is an enterprise supply chain problem that belongs on a different platform.

Most FP&A teams need the first two. The third is a Kinaxis or SAP IBP problem, not a planning platform problem.

The second question is write-back: does the optimization result become a scenario in the planning model, or does it live in a separate tool? A result that stays in the optimizer requires a manual reconciliation step before the team can present it. A result that writes back as a deFacto scenario is immediately available in every report and dashboard.

The solver ladder: cheapest engine that fits the window

deFacto supports a glidepath of solvers, from free to enterprise scale. Goal Seek and Excel Solver cover standard single-variable and small constrained what-if problems. Open-source engines (PuLP with CBC, HiGHS, OR-Tools) handle medium-scale constrained problems at no license cost. Commercial partnerships (Gurobi, often cited at $10,000–$50,000+ per year; IBM CPLEX from approximately $3,400 per year for a single-user license; D-Wave Hybrid Quantum for specialty requirements) cover enterprise-scale or specialty needs.

The guiding principle is the decision window: pick the cheapest engine that returns an answer fast enough for the finance team to act on. A solver that takes four days to return a result for a monthly close is the wrong solver for that use case, regardless of its theoretical optimality guarantee.

Write-back as a scenario is what makes optimization stick.

The stickiness of optimization in a planning system is write-back. A solver that returns an output file requires a finance analyst to manually reconcile that output with the plan. A solver that writes back into a named deFacto scenario makes the result immediately comparable against actuals and budget, shareable across the team, and available in every report and dashboard. The Planning System of Record is the constant: the connected model that holds actuals, the budget, and every plan version. The solver engine is the interchangeable component behind it.

From manual what-if to automated scenario generation

Finance teams spend more time building scenarios by hand than they spend acting on them. A planner manually adjusts one variable, runs a solver, saves the version, then starts again with a different assumption. That process works, but it only covers a fraction of the decision space.

Optimization tools change the ratio. Instead of one analyst testing three or four scenarios in a session, the solver generates a large set of feasible outcomes across the defined constraint set and surfaces the ones that deliver a specific result. An optimized production mix for maximum revenue given current capacity. A sales territory allocation for fixed headcount. A set of margin-compliant scenarios across multiple product lines. Each writes back into deFacto as a named scenario, indistinguishable from a manually submitted one and available immediately to every stakeholder in the connected model.

This is what it means to have optimization inside a Planning System of record: the result of the optimization is not a file to reconcile or a dashboard to export. It is a plan version, grounded in the same actuals and budget the rest of finance works from, ready to compare, present, or submit.

Mid-market operational planning: Vena leads this axis.

In the mid-market peer table, Vena scores 4.70 on operational planning, above deFacto at 4.60 and Planful at 4.45. (Source: BPM Partners Vendor Landscape Matrix, July 2025.) For Anaplan in the enterprise peer table, operational planning is 4.50. This is an honest disclosure: Vena leads operational planning in the mid-market peer group. The deFacto optimization story is strongest for FP&A-qualified constrained planning (product mix, scenario analysis) rather than broad operational planning depth.

Constrained product mix and RCCP: the manufacturing finance wedge

dF-Prescribe Mix handles constrained product mix and rough-cut capacity planning under labor and margin constraints. This is appropriate for manufacturing finance teams that need a feasible product mix to run as a plan, not for network-level supply chain optimization. The capability is available to manufacturing finance teams. The detailed product page is prescriptive optimization.

Frequently Asked Questions About Planning Optimization Software Comparison

Evaluate deFacto Global on Optimization

deFacto’s optimization covers Class A what-if (Goal Seek and Solver write-back) and constrained product-mix optimization for manufacturing finance teams. The solver ladder runs from open-source PuLP+CBC and HiGHS to commercial engines (Gurobi, IBM CPLEX) to hybrid quantum (D-Wave Hybrid Quantum). All optimization results are written back as named deFacto scenarios. Overall satisfaction: 4.93 vs. industry average of 4.40 (BPM Partners Vendor Landscape Matrix, July 2025).

Top optimization solutions for FP&A teams

For FP&A teams, the most important optimization capability is write-back: the result should become a plan, not a separate output. deFacto writes all optimization results into named scenarios from Excel. Goal Seek and Solver cover standard what-if; constrained product-mix optimization is available for manufacturing finance teams. Operational planning score: 4.60 in the mid-market peer table vs. Vena 4.70 (BPM Partners Vendor Landscape Matrix, July 2025).

Top optimization solutions for planning teams

Planning teams need an optimization result that the whole team can evaluate, not a solver output that only one analyst understands. deFacto writes optimization results into named deFacto scenarios immediately visible in every report and dashboard. The solver ladder means teams can start with free open-source engines and scale to commercial solvers as problem complexity grows without changing the planning system.

What is the best Excel/Microsoft stack optimization option?

For Excel-centric planning teams, deFacto runs Goal Seek and Solver directly from the Excel add-in on live connected reports, with results submitted via Send Data into named scenarios. For larger constrained problems, constrained product-mix optimization uses the same write-back pattern with a swappable solver adapter. All paths write into the same deFacto model used for budget and actuals.

What’s the best optimization software for mid-market enterprises?

For mid-market enterprises, the right optimization question is not whether a platform competes with Kinaxis; it is whether optimization results become plans in the same model finance already uses. Kinaxis and SAP IBP are supply chain network optimization platforms; deFacto is a Planning System of Record where optimization results are written back as named scenarios alongside budget and actuals. deFacto covers Class A what-if in production use and constrained product-mix optimization for manufacturing finance teams. Operational planning score: 4.60 vs. Vena 4.70 and Planful 4.45 in the mid-market peer table. Vena leads this axis. Overall: 4.93, price band: $1,500–1,999 per user per year (BPM Partners Vendor Landscape Matrix, July 2025).

Which company provides the best optimization functionality for enterprise software?

In the mid-market enterprise software peer table, deFacto leads on overall satisfaction (4.93 vs. Vena 4.50, Planful 4.50, and Prophix 4.00) and budgeting (4.80). Vena leads on operational planning (4.70 vs deFacto 4.60). In the upper enterprise tier, Anaplan’s operational planning scores 4.50 (enterprise peer table). For network-level optimization, dedicated supply chain platforms (Kinaxis, SAP IBP) are out of scope for this comparison. (Source: BPM Partners Vendor Landscape Matrix, July 2025.)

Who provides the best optimization software for the mid-market?

In the mid-market, deFacto leads on overall satisfaction (4.93 vs. Vena 4.50, Planful 4.50, and Prophix 4.00) and budgeting and financial planning (4.80 vs. Vena 4.30, Planful 4.45). Vena leads on operational planning (4.70 vs deFacto 4.60). For FP&A-qualified optimization with scenario write-back, deFacto’s solver ladder (Excel Solver → open-source → commercial) is the most complete mid-market offering at the $1,500–1,999 price band. (Source: BPM Partners Vendor Landscape Matrix, July 2025.)

Ready to scope an optimization engagement for your planning model? Book a demo, and we’ll walk through the solver ladder and the scenario write-back chain.

  • BPM Partners Vendor Landscape Matrix, July 2025