# Pigment Alternatives for Finance Teams That Plan in Excel

> Compare Pigment is a cloud planning platform whose planners work in its web application, with a published annual engagement of $3,000–$3,499 per user. In March 2026, its Modeler Agent introduced intent modeling: building a governed application from a description of the outcome. For finance teams evaluating deFacto as an alternative to Pigment, the key numbers [&hellip;]

**URL:** https://defactoglobal.com/compare/pigment/  
**Published:** 2026-08-14T16:50:04-04:00

---

Compare
Pigment is a cloud planning platform whose planners work in its web application, with a published annual engagement of $3,000–$3,499 per user. In March 2026, its Modeler Agent introduced intent modeling: building a governed application from a description of the outcome.


For finance teams evaluating deFacto as an alternative to Pigment, the key numbers are: deFacto $1,500–$1,999 per user for the year and Pigment $3,000–$3,499, alongside deFacto&#8217;s Excel-native planning and cloud or on-premises deployment. deFacto&#8217;s Agentic Application Development also builds an application from the outcome described, through the limited early-access program explained below.
Last reviewed: September 2026, against Pigment&#8217;s 4 March 2026 Modeler Agent launch.




Criterion
deFacto
Pigment




Where planners work
Excel-native. Same model in a Power BI visual via dF Reporter.
Pigment&#8217;s web application. A bi-directional Excel connector exists. The application itself lives in Pigment.


Deployment
Cloud or on-premises, same platform. Agentic Application Development: on-premises with self-hosted models, or OpenRouter with zero data retention and US/EU-only infrastructure.
Cloud


Annual engagement, per user
$1,500–$1,999 for the year. Not a monthly seat.
$3,000–$3,499 for the year. Not a monthly seat.


Revenue band in the July 2025 survey
$200 million–$5 billion
$1 billion–$10 billion


Build an application by describing the outcome
Agentic Application Development. Limited early access.
Modeler Agent, announced 4 March 2026


What the team receives
A licensed deFacto application, the data model, the database, and the Excel workbooks planners use
A Pigment application. Pigment states the Modeler Agent owns the logic and structure of the applications it generates.


AI that writes results into the plan
dF Foresight, dF Anomaly, dF Notify, and conversational agents
Analyst Agent, reporting, and predictions inside Pigment&#8217;s application





Plan in Excel, not in a new web application
deFacto planners enter and adjust the plan in Excel, while executives see the same governed numbers in a Power BI visual. dF Reporter writes changes back to the connected model, so the planning workbook and report use the same plan. Pigment&#8217;s Sheet View is an Excel-like view inside Pigment&#8217;s web application, and Pigment also has a bi-directional Excel connector. If the team wants its planning model in the workbooks it already uses, deFacto is the fit.


A lower annual engagement for the year you sign
For 50-user cloud planning in the July 2025 survey, deFacto&#8217;s annual engagement is $1,500–$1,999 per user for the year, compared with Pigment&#8217;s $3,000–$3,499. Those bands include user and platform fees; they are annual engagement figures rather than monthly seat prices. At the low ends, deFacto is half of Pigment; compare the full year you will sign. Overall satisfaction was 4.93 for deFacto in the mid-market peer table and 4.25 for Pigment in the enterprise peer table, which cover different populations.


On-premises when the plan has to stay in your environment
deFacto&#8217;s planning platform deploys in the cloud or on-premises from the same platform; Pigment&#8217;s surveyed deployment is cloud. The limited early-access application-building agents can run on-premises with self-hosted models, keeping agents and models in the customer&#8217;s environment. The alternative OpenRouter path, backed by Stripe, has a zero data retention policy and US/EU-only infrastructure: prompts are not retained and inference stays in US or EU infrastructure. For forecasting, cloud dF Foresight uses Nixtla TimeGPT-2.1 and writes results into the plan; teams requiring forecasting on their own infrastructure can use the sovereign AI path with Google TimesFM 2.5 or Nixtla NeuralForecast 3.2.


Agentic Application Development builds the application from the outcome you describe
A business owner describes the planning outcome in a requirements document or a conversation. Application-building agents generate the deFacto application, data model, database, and Excel workbooks. The application runs in the Planning System of Record, with permissions, calculation logic, and audit history from its first version. Pigment named this intent modeling in March 2026; deFacto brings it to teams in the $200 million–$5 billion survey revenue band whose planners work in Excel.
Pigment says its Modeler Agent owns the logic and structure of the applications it generates. With deFacto, the customer receives a licensed application and Excel workbooks a planner can open and an auditor can trace.
Agentic Application Development is available through a limited early-access program with named customers. The capabilities described here are being delivered with those customers and will be released more broadly as that program completes.


Forecasts, anomaly bands, and alerts write back into the plan
The application and its AI outputs use the same governed planning model. These four tools are available now, with or without Agentic Application Development:

dF Foresight forecasts time series with Nixtla TimeGPT-2.1, writing forecasts and confidence intervals into a chosen scenario. Planners can add drivers such as a planned price or cost change from Excel or the Power BI visual.
dF Anomaly detects anomalies in a selected window and writes a flag, lower band, and upper band into companion scenarios that finance can audit.
dF Notify watches subscribed values and alerts the team by email or in the Power BI visual.
Conversational agents answer from the connected planning model and product knowledge base. A variance analysis agent compares actuals, budget, forecast, comments, and audit in one pass.



When Pigment is the better fit
Pigment is a strong choice for a team that wants planning in a dedicated visual web application and an agent that evolves its existing model there. Pigment&#8217;s Custom Agents and Missions turn validated analysis conversations into recurring governed workflows. Its annual engagement of $3,000–$3,499 per user fits teams whose budget and cloud deployment requirements allow it. Pigment reported in March 2026 that it was approaching $100 million ARR, 56% of its 2025 new customers had migrated from legacy vendors, and 57% of new revenue came from enterprise customers. Choose deFacto when the team plans in Excel, needs an on-premises or zero data retention path, or is comparing annual engagement at $1,500–$1,999 per user.


Frequently asked questions

What is the best Excel-based alternative to Pigment?
deFacto is an Excel-native alternative: planners work in Excel and use the same governed model in a Power BI visual through dF Reporter. Its published annual engagement is $1,500–$1,999 per user, against Pigment&#8217;s $3,000–$3,499, and its platform deploys on-premises or in the cloud. Agentic Application Development builds an application from the desired outcome in limited early access.

Which planning platform costs half of Pigment on the annual engagement?
At the low ends of the published bands, deFacto&#8217;s $1,500 annual engagement per user is half of Pigment&#8217;s $3,000. The full bands are deFacto $1,500–$1,999 and Pigment $3,000–$3,499 per user for the year, including user and platform fees in a 50-user cloud planning comparison. Compare the annual engagement rather than a monthly seat quote.

Which planning platform can be installed on-premises instead of Pigment&#8217;s cloud?
deFacto&#8217;s planning platform deploys on-premises or in the cloud; Pigment&#8217;s surveyed deployment is cloud. In limited early access, deFacto&#8217;s application-building agents can run on-premises with self-hosted models, or through OpenRouter with zero data retention and US/EU-only infrastructure. The OpenRouter path is a retention and residency control, not an on-premises installation.

What is intent modeling, and does deFacto do it?
Intent modeling turns a description of a planning outcome into a governed application. Pigment named it with its Modeler Agent in March 2026. deFacto&#8217;s Agentic Application Development generates the application, data model, database, and Excel workbooks in a limited early-access program.

Does deFacto do what Pigment&#8217;s Modeler Agent does?
Both build governed planning applications from a description of the outcome. Pigment says its Modeler Agent owns the logic and structure of applications it generates and can evolve existing Pigment models; deFacto&#8217;s limited early-access agents produce a licensed application and Excel workbooks. deFacto suits Excel and on-premises requirements; Pigment suits teams committed to its web application.

Is Agentic Application Development available today?
Agentic Application Development is available through a limited early-access program with named customers. The capabilities described here are being delivered with those customers and will be released more broadly as that program completes. Excel-native planning, on-premises or cloud platform deployment, and write-back AI tools are available now, with or without Agentic Application Development.

Evaluating Pigment for an Excel-based finance team? Talk to us. We can compare the annual engagement and show where your planners work.
See also: Compare hub · Forecasting comparison · Analysis comparison · Anaplan comparison · AI planning software

Related pages

Compare forecasting in planning software
Compare reporting in planning platforms
Compare analysis and variance tools
Compare optimization in planning software
Excel alone vs Excel with a connected model
Power BI alone vs Power BI with planning write-back
Anaplan alternatives for mid-market finance teams
Vena alternatives for Excel-based planning teams
Workday Adaptive Planning alternatives
Planful alternatives for mid-market finance teams
OneStream alternatives for mid-market finance teams
Prophix alternatives for mid-market finance teams
Oracle EPM alternatives for mid-market finance teams
Jedox alternatives for Excel planning teams
Datarails alternatives for FP&amp;A teams
Cube alternatives for FP&amp;A teams
Lumel alternatives for Power BI planning teams


Sources

BPM Partners Vendor Landscape Matrix and Budgeting and Planning Buyers Guide, July 2025
Pigment, &#8220;On the path to $100M: Pigment launches AI Intent Modeling,&#8221; 4 March 2026
Nixtla TimeGPT-2.1
Stripe, &#8220;Stripe agrees to acquire OpenRouter,&#8221; 19 August 2026







Share this:
				Share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
				Facebook
			
				Share on X (Opens in new window)
				X
			Like this:Like Loading…